Civilisation has operated in two ways - To make one part of society more affluent and the other more wretched than would have been the lot of either in a natural state
There are Natural Rights and Civil Rights. Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness
Where Our Power to Execute Our Natural Rights is Perfect, Government has No Legitimate Jurisdiction
When the Forces for War are Greater than the Forces for Peace   Then the World is in Danger
Politics is not a Dirty Word. It is a Way of Life. How is Your Way of Life Today ?

GM Crops Killed No One – But Fed Millions More- Globalisation and Imperialism has Killed Millions

GMOs Don’t Hurt Anyone, But Opposing Them Does
By Hank Campbell | August 5th 2013 11:44 AM

About Hank

I’m the founder of Science 2.0® and co-author of “Science Left Behind”.

A wise man once said Darwin had the greatest idea anyone…

View Hank’s Profile

How do you demonize scientists who added 3 genes to the 30,000 in rice in order to stop vitamin A deficiencies in poor
countries with rice-dominated diets? There are zero pitfalls to it yet an elaborate, well-funded marketing campaign has been
leveled against it.

Ingo Potrykus and Peter Beyer genetically engineered their Golden Rice, called that because the genes they used for

producing beta carotene, a Vitamin A precursor, gave the rice grains a ‘golden’ color, and even persuaded companies to

waive patent rights so that they could give the seeds away for free.  No ‘Monsanto is evil’ nonsensical reasoning applies to

this, yet ‘green’ juggernauts like Greenpeace and Union of Concerned Scientists have opposed it by every means possible,

using lawyers and, of course, scare campaigns about biology.

How many kids have died in the 14 years this has been protested as “Frankenfood”? Estimates on deaths are always

somewhat overblown but activist groups love to throw them around so let’s give them one they can think about; as many as

18 million children have died due to vitamin A deficiency while they have blockaded just this one technology and another 18

million have gone blind, according to World Health Organization numbers. Deaths due to GMOs? Zero. Heck, stomach-aches

due to GMOs – still zero.

Matt Ridley at the Ottawa Citizen itemizes the manufactured outrage and nonsensical alternatives nicely and gets credit for

the bluntness of the title, except he comes right out and says ‘kills’:

golden rice was a corporate plot (untrue), did not produce enough vitamin A (not true), might cause health problems

(a vitamin enriched bowl of rice?), might upset ecosystems (unlikely for a domesticated crop) and that capsules of

vitamin A were a better bet (vitamin A capsules still reach too few people).

Well, no one said that reason and research were a part of anyone’s agenda against science. We all lament that political

discourse is so negative yet when it comes to science issues that go against personal beliefs, confirmation bias and ‘the

ends justify the means’ reasoning kicks in quite fast. People who are against science and the future will invent all kinds of

other reasons to mask their true motivations, like being anti-corporate, the precautionary principle, slippery slopes and the

goofiest logical fallacy, it can’t be ‘proved safe’.

Potrykus has been equally baffled by the left’s head in the sand on something so obvious, writing in Nature that “Regulation

must be revolutionized” (Nature  466, 561 July 29, 2010 doi:10.1038/466561a) – archaic mechanisms exploited by activists are

dooming more people than science will and that “I therefore hold the regulation of genetic engineering responsible for the

death and blindness of thousands of children and young mothers.”

Activist groups love two things; fundraising brochures and buying biohazard suits to wear in photo-ops while they commit

acts of terrorism. Credit and link: Guardian

I won’t just pick on Greenpeace. The ill-named left-wing advocacy group Union of Concerned Scientists, which until recently

was run by Kevin Knobloch, a former Democratic staffer, has been unfailingly opposed to every mainstream science

position except climate change. Golden Rice was “scientific garbage”, according to Doug Gurian-Sherman there.  Knobloch

has now gone back to directly being a Democratic staffer, he took a job as as chief of staff to Department of Energy (DOE)

Secretary Ernest Moniz. So the good news for kids in poor countries is that he is now dutifully helping to block energy

science rather than biological.

UCS knows so little about science they basically think if you eat too many carrots you will die from Vitamin A poisoning. ‘It

is toxic at high levels’ was the closest they got to a scientific argument against Golden Rice, even though it can’t happen.

While they promote their ‘you need to continue to test this until it is found harmful or you give up’ agenda against science,

children continue to suffer needlessly and die. Science can fix this. Science has a mandate to fix this. But scientists need to

stand up to groups like UCS with just as much unity as they stood with UCS in 2004, when everyone protested irrational

blockades of science by the Bush administration.

Obviously it isn’t just left-wing crackpots like UCS and Greenpeace who oppose biology. The conservative flagship

publication National Review carries a columnist who works for the Discovery Institute, which opposes evolution and is in

the scare journalism business about IVF and mean old science in general.

Also read: GM crops don’t kill kids. Opposing them does By Matt Ridley, Ottawa Citizen

Similar Recent Posts by this Author:

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email